Young Girls in Kashmir’s Garment Industry Are Losing Their Sight

Baseera Rafiqi
Posted October 20, 2017 from India

In Kashmir’s Budgam district, many young women make a living embroidering traditional garments and rugs. But the long hours and poor lighting are taking a serious toll on theireyesight.

WRITTEN BYBaseera RafiqiPUBLISHED ONOct. 16, 2017READ TIMEApprox. 4 minutes

At the garment shop where they work, Zahida Akhter, left, and Sakeena Bano spend at least nine hours a day doing complicated needlework squatting on the floor, often in low light.Baseera Rafiqi

BUDGAMDISTRICT, KASHMIR– On the outskirts of Srinagar, in Indian-administered Kashmir, most of the residents owe their livelihoods directly or indirectly to one thing: traditional Kashmiri garments. For many of them, producing or selling items such as shawls, namda (mats) and pheran (cloaks) is the only way they can make aliving.

But for the women who embroider the garments, the craft that pays their way has its own dire cost. Days spent hunched over delicate needlework, some of which can take months to complete, is taking a toll on their health. For some, it is even causing serious visionloss.

In one Budgam workshop, the sound of clicking looms mixes with the songs playing on the radio. Zahida Akhter, 18, sits in a corner near the windowsill to get more light as she puts the final touches on the cloak she is workingon.

Every day, she starts work at 9 a.m. and goes home at 6 p.m. After finishing her daily chores around 10 p.m., she sits down to continue working, usually by candlelight, until 3 a.m. After two hours’ sleep, she wakes up before her family to do more embroidery until it’s time for her to go back to the workshop. There are around 30 girls working with her, most of them under the age of18.

As a result of sitting hunched over her work for so many hours a day, she suffers from a slipped disc, swollen joints and deteriorating vision. “I was given glasses last year, but I never wore them,” she says. She felt they interfered with her ability to get up close to the cloth as she works. “I have severe headaches and backache after working throughout the day. But, well, one has to work to pay for life’s expenses,” shesays.

Doctors have recommended that she give up the work, but Akhter, who can barely read or write, says embroidery is the only way she can help provide for her family, which includes six younger siblings, all of them too young towork.

“How can I give it up as it is the only means for me to keep my family going?” she asks. “So, I don’t pay any attention to the doctor’srecommendations.”

There is no data available on the rates of visual impairment in Budgam district, but Dr. Mariyum Rubiya, an ophthalmologist who has been posted at the Budgam district hospital for over a year, says the number of patients she sees coming from the embroidery industry is on therise.

“For people like us, surviving is the main task. We can afford to take our chances with health and eyesight, but not with emptybellies.”

“Working intricate designs and keeping the piece very close to the eye for hours at a time eventually puts stress on the retina, and if this kind of thing continues, it has the tendency to affect the person’s eyesight,” she says. “I see two or three such patients per day, which amounts to about 720 a year. It’s a hugenumber.”

Rubiya says the women usually come in with headaches, for which she prescribes medication. She also recommends that the women start wearing glasses or take a break from their work. But they rarely listen, shesays.

“Most of the patients never follow up with their treatment, so it’s difficult to know how their condition [evolves] later on,” Rubiya says. Most of her patients, she says, are between the ages of 14 and 30, and come from lower socioeconomicgroups.

“For these young girls, protecting their eyesight is the most important thing, which we keep on telling them. But unfortunately, they stop coming to us as soon as we suggest they give up their work,” shesays.

Most of the embroiderers in Budgam are under Kashmir’s legal working age of 14, and some workshop owners openly admit they use girls as young as 12 because they are easier totrain.

“We prefer to take young and fresh minds to teach them about this art,” says Ramzan Mir, who owns three workshops employing more than 60 young girls, most of them minors. “As they are sharp enough at that age, they pick it up veryfast.”

But when a girl’s eyesight gets so bad she can no longer do the intricate needlework or her back hurts so much she can’t work for long stretches of time, she loses her job and often will struggle to findanother.

“This is unfortunate, but we tend to earn from others’ misery. First [the workshops] lure young girls with money, but then when their health starts to deteriorate, they declare them useless,” says local sociologist Dr. BashirAadil.

“It’s like blinding the coming generation, and we are doing absolutely nothing to preventit.”

Health experts in Budgam say working in the district’s garment industry has dire physical consequences for the underage girls employed as embroiderers. (BaseeraRafiqi)

Sakeena Bano, 26, works alongside Akhter. “It’s my fifth year in the business and each day, my strength decreases, owing to sitting at one place for hours,” she says. “My shoulders are cursing me; even my eyesight is diminishing with each passingday.”

Bano does much of her work at night, and the electricity supply to her home is unpredictable, so she often ends up using candles for light. Over the years, her eyesight has become so bad, it has started to affect herwork.

“Before, I could work throughout the night and the piece would come out very nicely. But now, I can see irregularities that are the outcome of my blurred vision,” she says. “I don’t get too many ordersnowadays.”

But, like Akhter, Bano sees no other option than to keep doing the work. Like most of the garment-makers in Budgam, Bano comes from an impoverished background and can’t read orwrite.

“For people like us, surviving is the main task,” she says. “We can afford to take our chances with health and eyesight, but not with emptybellies.”

Comments 8

Log in or register to post comments
Jill Langhus
Oct 21, 2017
Oct 21, 2017

Hi Baseera,

Thanks for sharing your sad story about these poor workers. Is there an organization there like the Occupational Safety and Health Administration in the U.S. that regulates health conditions, like hours they work, taking breaks, lighting, etc.? Or, can they start an etsy store or their own website so they can work their own hours? Even if a lot of them can't read or write, perhaps one of them can to at least start a store? What do you suggest for them?

Baseera Rafiqi
Oct 22, 2017
Oct 22, 2017

Dear , 

No there isnt any organization like that here.Well they can do that , I will help them ..

Jill Langhus
Oct 22, 2017
Oct 22, 2017

That's too bad about not having an organization for them, in their corner, but that would be awesome if you could help them create an online store. Let me know if you help them create one. I want to see it, follow it and share it:-) Much luck... Thank you!

Oct 26, 2017
Oct 26, 2017

Dear Baseera,

Poor working condition suffers health.  But what can a person make a change if this is the only thing she can do to bring food for the family especially if you came from poor family and no education.  I  hope that those who buy the products they produce would remember them that these garments worked hard with these women, remembering and appreciate that there are women who do these work so that they can earn a small amount.

Jackie Lidubwi
Oct 30, 2017
Oct 30, 2017

Dear Baseera,

Thank yo for highlighting the story, its very painful and sad, it is my hope that it will touch someone and the girls can be provided with alternative means of making a daily living.



May 11, 2018
May 11, 2018

Hi Baseera Rafiqi.

This story is a very moving story. Life shouldn't be so hard for girls this age! And 720 patients a year? That's horrible! What hurts the most is that the girls are being used, not just by their employers but also by the society, and then disposed of like tissue paper. That's totally unacceptable.

Some sort of remuneration or extra health benefits o scholarship should have been included in the package, and the girls should not be allowed to work after they leave the shop to their homes. I'm certain the clients can wait! If they need their order so urgently, then they will have to place an order much earlier.

I think also that apart from the employers of these girls, the health practitioners who examine these girls and see first hand how they are slowly losing their sight should step up and speak in favor of these girls to the hearing of the government or any labour organization or any human rights advocacy group. They possess hard tangible evidence of the detrimental effects of the long hours spent weaving these embroideries on the girls' health, and therefore I think that will lend credibility to their outcry.

They can't leave it to the girls to find their own way out of it.

There should also be a community sensitization campaign to draw the attention of the buyers of these embroidered products to the plight of the girls. The more voices, the better!

Please, it would give me great joy to hear that you have taken steps to place these suggestions before the powers that be, at least those within your reach.

I'm really looking forward to hearing feedback concerning this matter. Will you keep us posted, Baseera? Please?

Beth Lacey
May 15, 2018
May 15, 2018

I hope this story gets the attention it deserves and these people get the help they need

Chinyere Okoh
Jun 15, 2018
Jun 15, 2018

Such a touching article. At such a young young, they carry burdens beyond their years. The need to survive often encourage one to take up habits that even seem detrimental to their health.

Please keep me posted. I really would love to help. Also, I think you could post in the resource menu for support by an NGO. It would really go a long way.

Thanks for such enlightening post.